Shopify vs Big Cartel which is better? (2024 compared)

Today we'll be comparing Shopify vs Big Cartel , to ultimately help you decide which is the best solution for you. The information below is based on real data from our community of users like you, giving you a truly unbiased comparison. In the collection " Best eCommerce Website Builders (2024)" Big Cartel is ranked 3rd while Shopify is ranked 5th.

Big Cartel dominates with an overall user/editors rating of 3.6/5 stars with 1 reviews and Shopify user/editors rating is 3.4/5 stars with 3 reviews. This data is calculated in real-time from verified user reviews or editors rating if there isn't enough data for user rating.

If for whatever reason by the end of this comparison you are unable to choose between Shopify or Big Cartel, we have included a few useful alternatives like WooCommerce based on our community recommendations.

As far as Value for money goes, Big Cartel wins by 4 marks and Big Cartel is also voted as the easiest solution to use

Without further ado, let's look at a detailed breakdown of Shopify vs Big Cartel

Add Solutions

Pros & Cons

Why is Shopify better than Big Cartel?

FindrScore (fs) The Scoring is based on our unique algorithm that looks at reviews, votes, behavior, social signals and more. Learn more

+55

7 Reasons to consider this

Shopify is cheaper than Big Cartel
Compared to others the price is reasonable
A contender in E-commerce WordPress Plugins
A contender in eCommerce Website Builders
Has 0 highlight features
Best for Customer support
Best for Ease of use

Scroll Down for more details

Why is Big Cartel better than Shopify?

FindrScore (fs) The Scoring is based on our unique algorithm that looks at reviews, votes, behavior, social signals and more. Learn more

+88

8 Reasons to consider this

Compared to others the price is reasonable
Offers free plan with multiple advanced features
Great features list
Category leader in eCommerce Website Builders
Has 8 highlight features
Has Online Store
Has Site Customization
Has Products variants
Best for Customer support
Best for Ease of use
Best for Low cost software

Scroll Down for more details

Overview

Shopify

(3 votes)

N/A/5

Capterra

N/A/5

Trustpilot

Shopify is a popular name in the e-commerce industry, and it offers tons of features which are missing in every other plugin For the WordPress users, the product is available in the form of a plugin,... Read full review

Visit Website

Big Cartel

(1 vote)

N/A/5

Capterra

N/A/5

Trustpilot

If you are an artist or a maker, then Big Cartel is for you So, what is Big Cartel It is an easy online store created for makers and artists so that they can showcase and run their creative business... Read full review

Visit Website

Comparison winner

	Shopify 67 FS Compare	Big Cartel 79 FS Compare
Reviews
Starting Price		$9
Value for money	7/10	8/10
Quality of features score	6.6/10	7/10
Usability and Intuitiveness	6.6/10	7/10
Vendor Support	7/10	7/10
Likelihood of recommending
The reason for leaving
Site Customization		320%
Custom Domains		Unrated
Site Analytics		Unrated
File Storage		10%
Online Store		120%
SSL Certified		160%
Multiple Payment Methods		200%
Products variants		540%

Ratings

When evaluating weather to go with Shopify or Big Cartel which two criteria is most important to you.

Please select from the following and

Big Cartel offers the best value for money and is also the is easier to use — deciding between the two is a question of tradeoffs.

Standout Features

The SoftwareFindr Radar compares all solutions on our platform in your chosen category and tries to segment them to give you a visual representation of the market. All the solutions are compared two-dimensionally which takes into account their FindrScore which is given based on numerous data points and research frequency. The average FindrScore for products like Shopify is 46 which we've used as a threshold to only show the top 10 solutions.

The SoftwareFindr Radar compares all solutions on our platform in your chosen category and tries to segment them to give you a visual representation of the market. All the solutions are compared two-dimensionally which takes into account their FindrScore which is given based on numerous data points and research frequency. The average FindrScore for products like Shopify is 67 which we've used as a threshold to only show the top 10 solutions.

There is an old notion that higher price equals better quality, whilst that is sometimes the case. The chart above aims to give clarity whether there is a correlation between Price and the FindrScore.

Pricing

Pricing Model Subscription
Starting From $0 /
Free Trial
Promotional offer Shopify Deals
Check Shopify Pricing

Pricing Model Freemium, Subscription
Starting From $10 /
Free Trial
Promotional offer Big Cartel Deals
Check Big Cartel Pricing

$ 716.57

That is the average price for a solution in this field.

low Mid High

After analyzing 23 similar solutions the data above show that Magento offers the lowest starting price while Freelancer Marketplace Plugin offers the highest entry price.That being said is also worthtaking a closer look at what's on offer because sometimes you may get way more value for a solution with a higher entry price and vise versa.

Adoption By Geography

According to our data gathered on our platform Big Cartel is more popular in following countries - United States, Australia

According to our data gathered on our platform Shopify hasn't got a lead over Big Cartel in any country.

In order to give you more personalized recommendations, we tailor the ranking of a product to reflect what users are currently using in your geographical area.

Type of Support to Expect

70%

Continue to seek out vendors after Good Experience

70%

Continue to seek out vendors after Good Experience

Mail

Looking at data gathered on our platform the industry average for this category is 61.1% satisfaction rate which means both Shopify and Big Cartel is above this category average

Video Review

No Video Provided 1

Ranked in these collections

#3 Best eCommerce Website Builders

After analyzing the data on our platform, it's clear that whenever Shopify and Big Cartel go head to head within the same category Big Cartel has continued to be more popular over Shopify. This ranking data gives you a better understanding of how these solutions stack up in various use cases.

Average FindrScore in this Category

0%
Lowest score
49%
Average score
86%
Highest score

Shopify 67%
Big Cartel 79%

Shopify

Big Cartel

Behind the scenes

Hmm,sorry no one has uploaded a screenshot of the user interface yet.

Which Should You Choose

It's a win for Big Cartel ! Big Cartel offers Mail which users are happy with. Looking at the data gathered on our platform Big Cartel has a higher FindrScore of 79 which indicates that it could be a better fit over Shopify You have much more flexibility over Shopify when it comes to functionality. Hopefully, you now have a clear picture of Shopify and Big Cartel pricing, features and user-experience provided these solutions. Both have pros and cons and which you choose will depend on your integration needs, pricing and more. Whichever solution you go with, please come back and leave a review for that product so others can benefit from your experience.

Visit Website

Frequently Asked Questions

Q. Is Big Cartel better than Shopify?

Ans. We have analyzed 7080 data points to answer this question, in 2024 Big Cartel is better than Shopify. the scoring 88 whilst Shopify scored 55

Q. For beginners which is better Big Cartel or Shopify?

Ans. We ask this very question to our readers and the results are in, Big Cartel scored better that Shopify by 4 points crowing it the most user friendly.

Q. What's the price difference between Big Cartel and Shopify?

Ans. The solutions are priced slightly different so calculating the price would need to be over a set period. Shopify is subscription whilst Big Cartel is freemium,

Q. What is the difference between Big Cartel and Shopify?

Ans. The main difference beyond price and support, is Big Cartel has an overall higher FindrScore which looks at over 7080 data points powered by real user testing and overall satisfaction.

Q. Out of Big Cartel and Shopify which as the better support?

Ans. The data gathered shows that Big Cartel as a slightly better user satisfaction that Shopify.

Q. What are a few good alternatives to Big Cartel and Shopify?

Ans. Users who research Big Cartel and Shopify also look at WooCommerce which as a FindrCsore of 66, See 23 more similar solutions

Q. Big Cartel or Shopify which is good for beginners?

Ans. Looking at the scorecard for both these products, the results show that Big Cartel is better for beginners

Q. Which is better, Big Cartel or Shopify in 2024?

Ans. We’ve asked this very question to users like you and the results are in. The majority of users are recommending Big Cartel.

Q. How does Big Cartel compare to Shopify?

Ans. The main difference beyond price and support, is Big Cartel has an overall higher FindrScore which looks at over 7080 data points powered by real user testing and overall satisfaction

Other Alternatives to consider

So Shopify and Big Cartel isn't cutting it for you? Here are a few alternatives with similar features that users on our platform also looked at. For a more in-depth breakdown, we always recommend checking out the dedicated alternative page which gives more data on why which solution is recommended. If the price is a big factor to you, the WooCommerce might be worth looking at. For an all-round great solution, then Magento as the highest FindrScore.